A federal judge late yesterday reinstated the Bureau of Land Management’s 2016 methane waste rule, aimed at protecting people and the climate from methane waste and pollution from oil and gas extraction on public lands. The ruling is the third defeat for the Trump administration’s efforts to suspend, delay or repeal the rule.
The rule requires oil and gas companies operating on public lands to take reasonable measures to prevent the waste of publicly owned fossil gas. It will go back into effect in 90 days. Such measures significantly reduce pollution from methane, a dangerous greenhouse gas 86 times more potent than carbon dioxide, and are an important step to address the climate crisis.
“The Trump administration has abused every opportunity — legal or otherwise — to maximize the oil and gas industry’s profits at the expense of taxpayers, public health, and the climate,” said Erik Schlenker-Goodrich, executive director of the Western Environmental Law Center. “We welcome the court’s forceful repudiation of the Trump administration’s reckless and unlawful conduct.”
In 2018 a broad coalition of conservation and citizens’ groups challenged the cancellation of most provisions of the rule after defeating prior Trump administration attempts to end these protections. In today’s ruling the court found the administration had downplayed the significance of the rule’s benefits to public health, local communities and the climate. The court also determined the Bureau’s cost-benefit analysis ignored global climate costs.
Reviewing the BLM’s effort to undo the methane waste rule, the court found “the rulemaking process resulting in the Rescission was wholly inadequate. In its haste, BLM ignored its statutory mandate under the Mineral Leasing Act, repeatedly failed to justify numerous reversals in policy positions previously taken, and failed to consider scientific findings and institutions relied upon by both prior Republican and Democratic administrations.”
“It’s despicable that the Trump administration has repeatedly tried to gut modest protections for our lungs and our climate to benefit a dirty, climate-destroying industry,” said Michael Saul, a senior attorney at the Center for Biological Diversity. “We’re grateful that the courts continue to reject these unscientific, indefensible attempts to give fossil-fuel companies a license to pollute.”
The coalition’s lawsuit sought to reinstate the 2016 rule to reduce methane waste and pollution and address the longstanding problem of reduced production royalties caused when the fossil-fuel industry wastes publicly owned methane. The U.S. Government Accountability Office estimates lost royalties at nearly $23 million annually under the pre-2016 regime. The 2016 rule will help taxpayers reclaim about $800 million in royalties over the next decade.
A Delaware-sized methane “hot spot” in New Mexico’s San Juan Basin is the major contributor to San Juan County’s “F” grade on ozone from the American Lung Association. In Texas and New Mexico’s Permian Basin, recently the highest-producing oil basin in the world, gas flaring is now at an all-time high of 750 million cubic feet per day. That’s a 650 percent increase over less than a decade, and the highest emissions ever recorded from a U.S. oil and gas basin. These data show that voluntary methane waste measures aren’t working.
In addition to flaring and methane emissions, gas waste associated with oil and gas development results in smog pollution and releases other toxic pollutants, such as benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and xylene.
The 2016 rule was crafted over four years with input from the oil and gas industry. It accounted for nearly 300,000 public comments and earned approval from 75 percent of Westerners.
“At a time when the current administration has taken many measures that prioritize corporate profits over public health, we applaud the court’s decision to reinstate protections against methane waste pollution that will allow the health of our Indigenous communities to flourish from better air quality,” said Carol Davis with Diné CARE.
“This District Court decision rejects the Trump administration’s reckless and unlawful attempts to rollback protections for air, public health, and communities threatened and harmed by fracking on public lands,” said Bruce Baizel, Energy Program Director at Earthworks. “The decision further affirms the rightful role for considerations of climate impacts on future Bureau of Land Management considerations.”
“The Bureau’s methane rule is a common-sense solution to protect our climate, reduce air pollution and save taxpayer money,” said Will Roush, executive director of Wilderness Workshop. “The court’s reinstatement of the rule is step forward for people across the west and especially those in communities disproportionately impacted by pollution from oil and gas development.”
“Today’s decision protects our forests, parks, wildlife refuges, and monuments from harmful greenhouse gasses caused by oil development,” said Los Padres ForestWatch Executive Director Jeff Kuyper. “From the Sespe to the Carrizo Plain and beyond, California’s public lands—and the communities that depend on them—can all breathe a lot easier.”
“Methane is one of the most potent greenhouse gases—and the Bureau of Land Management’s attempted rescission of the 2016 common-sense methane-control rule would have added fuel to the fire that is the climate crisis. The agency’s decision would have also let a public resource be needlessly burnt away or released into thin air,” said Jim Murphy, director of legal advocacy for the National Wildlife Federation. “The Bureau of Land Management’s rule was clearly misguided, grossly uninformed by science and, as the court has ruled, blatantly illegal. The Department of the Interior should take stock of this ruling and rethink its myopic and destructive pursuit of energy development at all costs.”
“For over three years, this administration has attempted to get rid of BLM’s waste rule based on a myriad of inadequate justifications, trying to grant favors to their corporate friends at the expense of the public’s well-being,” said Darin Schroeder, attorney from Clean Air Task Force who co-represented National Wildlife Federation with the Western Environmental Law Center. “We are grateful that the rule of law has yet again prevailed.”
The Western Environmental Law Center represented the Center for Biological Diversity, Citizens for a Healthy Community, Diné Citizens Against Ruining Our Environment, Earthworks, Los Padres ForestWatch, Montana Environmental Information Center, San Juan Citizens Alliance, WildEarth Guardians, Wilderness Workshop and Wyoming Outdoor Council in the case. The Western Environmental Law Center and Clean Air Task Force jointly represented the National Wildlife Federation.
Erik Schlenker-Goodrich, Western Environmental Law Center, 575-613-4197, gro.w1604189863alnre1604189863tsew@1604189863gskir1604189863e1604189863
Stuart Ross, Clean Air Task Force, 914-649-5037, su.ft1604189863ac@ss1604189863ors1604189863
Michael Saul, Center for Biological Diversity, 303-915-8308, gro.y1604189863tisre1604189863vidla1604189863cigol1604189863oib@l1604189863uasm1604189863
Natasha Leger, Citizens for a Healthy Community, 970-399-9700, gro.u1604189863oy4ch1604189863c@ahs1604189863atan1604189863
Carol Davis, Diné Citizens Against Ruining Our Environment, 928-319-0006, email@example.com
Justin Wasser, Earthworks, 202-887-1872 x136, gro.s1604189863krowh1604189863trae@1604189863ressa1604189863wj1604189863
Jeff Kuyper, Los Padres ForestWatch, 805-770-3401, gro.w1604189863fpl@f1604189863fej1604189863
Derf Johnson, Montana Environmental Information Center, 406-581-4634, gro.c1604189863iem@n1604189863osnho1604189863jd1604189863,
Mike Saccone, National Wildlife Federation, 202-797-6634, gro.f1604189863wn@me1604189863nocca1604189863s1604189863
Mark Pearson, San Juan Citizens Alliance, 970-259-3583 x1, gro.s1604189863nezit1604189863icnau1604189863jnas@1604189863kram1604189863
Jeremy Nichols, WildEarth Guardians, 303-437-7663, gro.s1604189863naidr1604189863aught1604189863raedl1604189863iw@sl1604189863ohcin1604189863j1604189863
Will Roush, Wilderness Workshop, 206-979-4016, gro.p1604189863ohskr1604189863owsse1604189863nredl1604189863iw@ll1604189863iw1604189863
Alan Rogers, Wyoming Outdoor Council, 307-262-9865, gro.l1604189863icnuo1604189863crood1604189863tuogn1604189863imoyw1604189863@nala1604189863