Amigos Bravos offers reporters two new resources for tracking the produced water issue in New Mexico. The group commissioned two new white papers examining the risks to human health and environment and the feasibility of the reuse and discharge of treated oil and gas wastewater. The studies find significant shortcomings in scientific advancements and feasibility of treated produced water reuse and discharge.

In 2025, the New Mexico Water Quality Control Commission (WQCC) adopted a rule prohibiting the discharge of treated produced water in the state and allowing its use in non-discharging pilot projects for research. Even before the rule went into effect in July 2025, an industry group petitioned the WQCC to undertake a new rulemaking to broadly allow treated produced water reuse and discharge to New Mexico’s rivers, streams, acequias, cropland, and ground water. WQCC voted to undertake this rulemaking to reverse the prohibition based on an assertion that New Mexico Produced Water Research Consortium (NMPWRC) research shows reuse is safe. Industry is also pushing for legislation that would require the WQCC to pass rules to allow discharge and reuse. A hearing has yet to be scheduled for 2027.

The new white papers:

Produced Water in New Mexico: A Critical Review of Recent Toxicity and Risk Assessment Literature

Christopher Lewis, ScD, and Ann Jones, PhD, at Industrial Economics, Inc. Fact sheet here.

The NMPWRC research represents progress on treatment technologies, yet even the authors of the studies acknowledge that work remains. A handful of small bench and pilot-scale studies, none reproduced independently and none addressing fate and transport, does not amount to a comprehensive or adequate risk evaluation. These substantial gaps mean that the safety to human health and the environment from discharge of treated produced water has not not been established and the discharge prohibition should be maintained while research continues.

Beneficial Reuse of Treated Produced Water: Assessing Feasibility and Sustainability

Dan Mueller, PE. Fact sheet here.

Overall, beneficial reuse of treated produced water, while promising, is technically unproven, economically uncertain, and limited by unresolved sustainability concerns. The appropriate path forward is a deliberate, transparent, and independently evaluated process that establishes treatment performance, protects human health and the environment, demonstrates full-cost economic viability, and addresses long-term water-supply reliability and waste-management responsibility. Decisionmakers must rely on scientifically defensible, reproducible data—not assumptions—to avoid creating new environmental, public-health, or financial liabilities while attempting to address the oil and gas industry’s produced-water management challenges.

Please reach out to Rachel Conn, and/or Tannis Fox with any questions.

Contacts:

Rachel Conn, Amigos Bravos, 575-770-8327, rconn@amigosbravos.org

Tannis Fox, Western Environmental Law Center, 505-629-0732, fox@westernlaw.org

en_USEnglish
Skip to content