Judge Fails to Halt Fracking in Greater Chaco

Hopes for a respite from a fracking boom plaguing Navajo and public lands in New Mexico’s Greater Chaco area were thwarted Friday when a federal judge failed to grant a temporary halt to drilling. Despite the lack of environmental review or a comprehensive plan for fracking in the area, the Bureau of Land Management will be allowed to continue to grant hundreds or even thousands of new permits to drill and frack the area.

BLM has never studied the impacts of fracking on local communities, the area’s unparalleled cultural history, or to air, water, or the climate. To address this shortcoming, a coalition of Navajo and environmental groups requested a preliminary injunction to put a stop to the drilling, which they believe violates the National Environmental Policy Act. While no final decision has yet been made by plaintiffs, an appeal of today’s ruling is likely. Environmental organizations that filed for the preliminary injunction will continue challenging oil and gas development in the Greater Chaco area and will increase oversight of individual oil and gas projects proposed by BLM.

The Greater Chaco area is home to Navajo and other communities living amid extensive new oil and gas development that threatens their way of life. The area is also home to one of the country’s most important archaeological sites, Chaco Culture National Historical Park. Extensive ancestral Puebloan ruins throughout the landscape make this the ancient cultural heart of the American Southwest.

“We are dismayed by Friday’s decision from Judge Browning because full-scale, unregulated oil and gas development continues to impose devastating impacts on human, cultural, and environmental resources on Dinétah (Navajo homelands) and surrounding areas,” said Colleen Cooley of Diné Citizens Against Ruining Our Environment.

Today’s ruling comes not long after Senator Udall and top Interior Department officials visited the area and vowed to assure that serious impacts from fracking would be held in check. Previously, BLM had placed a 10-mile buffer around the National Park to prevent further leasing, but refused to place limits on new permits to drill. The park superintendent has asked that the buffer be made permanent.

“Judge Browning ruled on Friday that continued unstudied shale oil development is more important than the health of Greater Chaco communities and the area’s priceless cultural resources,” said Kyle Tisdel, climate and energy program director at the Western Environmental Law Center. “This decision is wrong for the people of Greater Chaco, and illustrates how some truly believe Greater Chaco is a ‘sacrifice zone’ to be exploited and thrown away.”

“While this decision is discouraging, we believe that BLM has failed the public and continues piecemeal approval of new oil development, neglecting cumulative impacts, resulting in significant flaring waste and industrializing the landscape,” said Mike Eisenfeld, New Mexico Coordinator for San Juan Citizens Alliance. “This is not over. We will reassess and challenge this injustice.”

An intensely industrial form of fossil fuel development, horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, has besieged the region with dangerous truck traffic and a vast network of new roads, oil tanks, pipelines, flares and fracking equipment. BLM’s drilling plan for the area would allow thousands of fracking permits, forever changing the character of the region.

“BLM is out of control in its mad rush to permit fracking in Greater Chaco, and for that matter, across the West,” said Samantha Ruscavage-Barz, staff attorney with WildEarth Guardians. “We won’t – we can’t let today’s ruling slow our efforts to stop fracking on our public lands, both to protect those lands and to protect our climate from these dirty fuels.”

“Despite recognizing that fracking in the Chaco area could cause irreparable harm to people’s health and the environment, this decision allows fracking to continue unabated on our public lands while the lawsuit plays out,” said Matthew McFeeley, staff attorney with the Natural Resources Defense Council. “We’ll keep fighting to protect the public from runaway oil and gas development, in New Mexico and around the country.”

While the ruling may not have favored public interest, a growing coalition of groups continues to call for leadership in protecting Greater Chaco from fracking. On Tuesday, youth will deliver 160,000 petitions to New Mexico congressional delegation offices in Santa Fe and Albuquerque requesting a moratorium on fracking in the Greater Chaco area.

The plaintiffs in the lawsuit are Diné Citizens Against Ruining Our Environment, San Juan Citizens Alliance, WildEarth Guardians and Natural Resources Defense Council. Attorneys from the Western Environmental Law Center and WildEarth Guardians represent the groups.

Contacts:

Colleen Cooley, Diné Citizens Against Ruining Our Environment, 928-637-3221, moc.l1734685418iamg@173468541822yel1734685418oocc1734685418
Kyle Tisdel, Western Environmental Law Center, 575-613-8050, gro.w1734685418alnre1734685418tsew@1734685418ledsi1734685418t1734685418
Mike Eisenfeld, San Juan Citizens Alliance, 505-325-6724, gro.1734685418snezi1734685418ticna1734685418ujnas1734685418@ekim1734685418
Jeremy Nichols, WildEarth Guardians, 303-437-7663, gro.s1734685418naidr1734685418aught1734685418raedl1734685418iw@sl1734685418ohcin1734685418j1734685418
Kate Kiely, Natural Resources Defense Council, 212-727-4592, gro.c1734685418drn@y1734685418leikk1734685418

A copy of Friday’s decision is available here.

A copy of the May 11, 2015, plaintiff’s memorandum in support of their motion for preliminary injunction is available here.

A copy of the May 21, 2015, amended complaint is available here.

Read more about our work to protect Greater Chaco from fracking.