After defeats in court and in Congress, the Trump administration is now attempting to suspend for one year almost all of the requirements of its Methane Waste Prevention Rule that would reduce waste of publicly owned natural gas by oil and gas companies. Today, government watchdog groups filed a lawsuit to halt this illegal move.
Before even receiving comment on the rule, Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke represented to a federal court that he would delay the rule, thoroughly undermining the meaningfulness of public comment. The BLM then conducted a go-through-the-motions notice-and-comment process—featuring a lightning-fast comment period, and next-to-no stakeholder outreach culminating in a final rule that largely ignored citizen concerns. This is not how the law is designed to work. The law requires a reasoned give-and-take between the affected public and the agency that is designed to infuse democratic legitimacy into agency rulemaking. Here, the secretary’s closed mind prevented that important give-and-take.
“Interior’s BLM methane waste rule delay flies in the face of overwhelming public support, Congress’ recent rejection of an attempt to repeal the rule, a federal court’s determination that an injunction halting implementation of the rule was not warranted, and, fundamentally, core precepts of federal law” said Erik Schlenker-Goodrich, executive director of the Western Environmental Law Center. “Methane waste seriously and urgently threatens our climate, our pocketbook, and public health. If there was any doubt who Sec. Zinke serves in his position, it’s now abundantly clear it’s not the American public.”
“The methane waste rule delay is yet another action taken by the Trump Administration to benefit the oil and gas industry at the expense of the American public, particularly the millions of Westerners who use public lands for many activities including ranching, hunting, hiking and other forms of outdoor recreation. Those Americans, and others who visit these public lands, are negatively impacted by the oil and gas industry’s wasteful practices,” said Darin Schroeder, attorney with the Clean Air Task Force which is co-representing National Wildlife Federation.
“Oil and gas companies are recklessly dumping high levels of methane into the atmosphere,” said Michael Saul, senior attorney with the Center for Biological Diversity. “It’s not just wasteful and harmful to public health, but the Trump administration is trying to let them get away with it. The lawsuit aims to hold the Trump administration accountable and prevent it from illegally suspending modest requirements to limit this potent greenhouse gas.”
The BLM waste rule, finalized in 2016, updates antiquated, 30-year old regulations. It requires companies to fix leaky, faulty equipment and reduce natural gas waste on public lands. According to the U.S. Government Accountability Office, enough natural gas was unnecessarily wasted and leaked between 2009 and 2015 to serve more than 6 million households for a year. The updated waste rule requires companies to perform leak detection and repair with affordable, off-the-shelf technologies, and restricts methane venting (deliberately releasing gas into the atmosphere), and flaring (burning off gas unused at the wellhead). The Trump administration’s decision to delay implementation of the BLM waste rule would allow industry to avoid these common-sense waste reduction measures, and continue to unnecessarily waste our publicly owned resources while the administration attempts to figure out how to kill the rule outright as a gift to its oil and gas benefactors. Methane waste not only shortchanges taxpayers, it harms public health and contributes significantly to climate emissions.
- Waste: According to Interior, in 2014, oil and gas companies wasted more than 4 percent of the natural gas they produced on federal lands, sufficient gas to supply nearly 1.5 million households with gas for a year.
- Public health: Methane released by the oil and gas industry comes packaged with other toxic pollutants— benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, xylene — and smog-forming volatile organic compounds that harm communities.
- Climate: Methane is a greenhouse gas 87 times more potent than carbon dioxide during the time it remains in the atmosphere.
- Taxpayers: The BLM methane waste rule, if left in place, would earn taxpayers about $800 million in royalties on publicly owned methane resources over the next decade. Since 1980, lax provisions have resulted in BLM rubber-stamping industry requests to vent and flare natural gas and to avoid paying royalties. The U.S. Government Accountability Office estimates lost royalties at nearly $23 million annually under the antiquated regime.
Notably, the oil and gas industry failed in three prior attempts to derail the rule. In January 2017, a federal judge in the U.S. District Court for the District of Wyoming denied a motion to enjoin the methane rule. In May 2017, the U.S. Senate voted to reject legislation advanced under the Congressional Review Act to eliminate the rule. And, in October 2017, a federal magistrate judge in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California ruled that an attempt by the secretary to stay the rule’s compliance dates without notice or an opportunity for comment violated the law.
Laura King, Western Environmental Law Center, 406-204-4852, gro.w1558709317alnre1558709317tsew@1558709317gnik1558709317
Stuart Ross, Clean Air Task Force, 914-649-5037, su.ft1558709317ac@ss1558709317ors1558709317
Michael Saul, Center for Biological Diversity, 303-915-8308, gro.y1558709317tisre1558709317vidla1558709317cigol1558709317oib@l1558709317uasm1558709317
Natasha Leger, Citizens for a Healthy Community, 970-399-9700, gro.u1558709317oy4ch1558709317c@ahs1558709317atan1558709317
Carol Davis, Diné Citizens Against Ruining Our Environment, 928-221-7859, email@example.com
Hilary Lewis, Earthworks, 202-887-1872 x101, gro.n1558709317oitca1558709317skrow1558709317htrae1558709317@siwe1558709317lh1558709317
Anne Hedges, Montana Environmental Information Center, 406-443-2520, gro.c1558709317iem@s1558709317egdeh1558709317a1558709317
Jim Murphy, National Wildlife Federation, 802-595-5268, gro.f1558709317wn@yh1558709317prumj1558709317
Mark Pearson, San Juan Citizens Alliance, 970-259-3583 x1, gro.s1558709317nezit1558709317icnau1558709317jnas@1558709317kram1558709317
Jeremy Nichols, WildEarth Guardians, 303-437-7663, gro.s1558709317naidr1558709317aught1558709317raedl1558709317iw@sl1558709317ohcin1558709317j1558709317
Peter Hart, Wilderness Workshop, 303-475-4915, gro.p1558709317ohskr1558709317owsse1558709317nredl1558709317iw@re1558709317tep1558709317
Mary Flanderka, Wyoming Outdoor Council, 307-290-0069, gro.l1558709317icnuo1558709317crood1558709317tuogn1558709317imoyw1558709317@fyra1558709317m1558709317