Today, the U.S. Senate voted 62-33 to pass the most damaging environmental and community protection rollback in American history. The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) now advances to the House of Representatives. The Senate rushed to pass the bill—written in secret and only released to the public and even other legislators on September 30, 2026—without holding a single committee hearing. Bill sponsors inserted BAAJA into H.R. 2347, the Survivor Justice Tax Prevention Act, replacing a bill intended to protect victims of sexual assault, to circumvent the committee hearing process.

BAAJA would cause grave, generational harm to the West’s public lands, waters and wildlife, and communities. It would functionally repeal the National Environmental Policy and Historic Preservation Acts by depriving the courts of the power to vacate unlawful permits or otherwise take action to prevent the irreparable harm caused by unlawfully approved permits, turning the U.S. Magna Carta of environmental laws into a paper tiger. Compounding the damage, BAAJA would impinge on the right of states and Tribes to protect their rivers, streams, and wetlands by virtue of severely weakening the Clean Water Act. Further, it would weaken the Endangered Species Act, making it far harder for the federal government to conserve and restore imperiled species in the face of uncertainty caused, for example, by climate change. Outside the traditional domain of environmental law, BAAJA would accelerate Trump’s vanity projects such as the “triumphal arch” and White House “ballroom,” and remove barriers designed to impose meaningful consideration before building unwanted, cruel, and wasteful immigrant detention centers.

Overall, the bill, by weakening these bedrock laws, would make it far easier to fast-track AI data centers as well as fossil fuel, mining, and other extractive infrastructure. Once these projects are approved, they would be difficult to unwind. BAAJA includes a “project certainty” provision that would strictly limit the ability of a future presidential administration to revisit Trump-era project approvals, even if that administration found the Trump administration had approved them unlawfully. Meanwhile, an additional “project certainty” provision would hobble the power of a future president to deprioritize fossil fuels and incentivize renewable infrastructure by prohibiting “disparate treatment” of fossil fuels, a legal concept noxiously pulled from anti-discrimination law. Many provisions of the bill can be found in far-right policy blueprint Project 2025.

Senate Democrats supporting BAAJA contend that it is needed for renewable energy buildout. But President Trump has explicitly stated he will not approve wind energy projects even if he signs the bill into law. Further, the U.S. grid interconnection queue has shifted dramatically over the past two years, reversing a trend towards renewable power generation. In August 2024, 26% of the U.S. interconnection queue (based on potential generation) was for fossil fuels while, in August 2026, 51% of the queue was for fossil fuels–a function of data center demand growth.

Democrats pushing the bill have also cited “affordability” as a main justification. This argument is wildly overstated. Rhodium, the analysis relied upon by BAAJA’s supporters, concluded that estimated median household electricity costs in 2035 would decline from $2,200 a year to $2,134 a year. This decline, roughly equivalent to the cost of one cup of coffee each month, is indistinguishable from normal price fluctuations from weather. Meanwhile, we are unaware of any analysis that estimates the vast profits for AI technology, energy, and finance interests, which could likely reach into the hundreds of billions of dollars.

BAAJA is widely and fiercely opposed by Tribes and Indigenous groups, state attorneys general, and advocacy organizations focusing on environmental justice, climate, public lands, ocean conservation, civil rights, faith, immigration, human rights, archaeology, and public health. Even outdoor retailers including REI and Patagonia took the extraordinary step of publicly opposing BAAJA. Key BAAJA proponents include the American Petroleum Institute, Data Center Coalition, and National Mining Association.

“We urge the House of Representatives, in particular elected leaders who care about the West’s public lands, waters and wildlife, and communities to reject this bill. This is the single most important vote on environmental and community protections since our bedrock environmental laws were passed into law by overwhelming bipartisan majorities in the 1970s. We are watching,” said Erik Schlenker-Goodrich, executive director of the Western Environmental Law Center. “There is a constructive conversation to be had in the 120th Congress to build out renewables infrastructure and deliver on the promise of affordability, while respecting people and place through thoughtful updates to NEPA and other permitting laws. That conversation should proceed through regular order to bring new ideas to the table and ensure all voices are heard.”

A coalition of 29 groups in Sen. Heinrich’s home state of New Mexico with diverse focus areas including Indigenous, faith, children’s health, clean water, conservation, climate, and community issues sent him a letter opposing the bill last week. He ignored those constituents.

New Mexico Gov.-elect Deb Haaland as well as Reps. Melanie Stansbury and Teresa Leger Fernàndez vocally oppose BAAJA. New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez led a group of six state attorneys general in a letter opposing the bill.

Contacts:
Erik Schlenker-Goodrich, Western Environmental Law Center, 575-751-0351, eriksg@westernlaw.orgMarlyn Twitchell, Western Environmental Law Center, 541-485-2471, ext. 144, twitchell@westernlaw.org

Resources:

  • Veteran Attorney David Bookbinder excoriates BAAJA as a threat to American democracy in a memo here.
  • A national Earthjustice poll found that “Given a choice, 77% of voters said the U.S. should maintain existing laws that protect the environment and public health even if some projects take longer to build. Only 23% preferred building faster if it meant weakening environmental laws.”

Groups that have publicly opposed BAAJA:

Indigenous and Tribal
Indigenous Environmental Network; Honor the Earth; Western Shoshone Defense Project; Indigenous Lifeways; Native American Rights Fund; The Klamath Tribes’ Culture and Heritage Department; National Congress of American Indians; Diné Citizens Against Ruining Our Environment; New Mexico Native Vote; Sovereign Energy; Naeva

Civil rights, democracy and progressive groups
ACLU, NAACP, Black Voters Matter Fund; Our Revolution; Progressive Democrats of America; Muslims for Just Futures; Grassroots Global Justice Alliance; New York Communities for Change; Common Ground Rising; People Power United; Community Alliance for Global Justice; Black Lives Matter Louisville; Veterans For Peace (Baltimore chapter); Environmental Issues Team of Indivisible Santa Cruz County; Center for Civic Policy; New Mexico Voices for Children; The Semilla Project; ProgressNow New Mexico

Faith groups
Unitarian Universalist Association; Unitarian Universalist Service Committee; Unitarian Universalists for Social Justice; GreenFaith; Creation Justice Ministries; Dayenu: A Jewish Call to Climate Action; Mennonite Central Committee U.S.; Virginia Interfaith Power & Light; Church Women United in New York State; Unitarian Universalist Action New Hampshire; Maine Unitarian Universalist State Advocacy Network; New Mexico Interfaith Power & Light

Consumer and public interest
Consumer Federation of America; Center for Progressive Reform; New York Public Interest Research Group; Virginia Citizens Consumer Council; Green America; Green Amendments For The Generations; Private Equity Stakeholder Project; Income Movement; Center for Organizing; Next 100 Coalition

Technology and media
AI Now Institute; Free Press Action; MediaJustice; Media Alliance; TechTonic Justice; Labor Tech Research Network; Progressive Technology Project; Until Justice Data Partners

Health and labor
National Nurses United; Physicians for Social Responsibility; San Francisco Bay Physicians for Social Responsibility; Oregon Physicians for Social Responsibility; Science and Environmental Health Network; AFGE Local 704; Therapists for Peace & Justice

Mining and land use
Great Basin Resource Watch; Arizona Mining Reform Coalition; Basin and Range Watch; Patagonia Area Resource Alliance; Save the Scenic Santa Ritas Association; Gila Resources Information Project; Citizens to Protect Smith Valley, NV

Conservation, wildlife and forests
Center for Biological Diversity; Defenders of Wildlife; Southern Environmental Law Center; Western Environmental Law Center; WildEarth Guardians; Western Watersheds Project; Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance; Great Old Broads for Wilderness; Wilderness Watch; Conservation Northwest; Idaho Conservation League; Cascadia Wildlands; Oregon Wild; Oregon Natural Desert Association; Rocky Mountain Wild; San Juan Citizens Alliance; Alliance for the Wild Rockies; Friends of the Clearwater; Friends of the Boundary Waters Wilderness; Southeast Alaska Conservation Council; Cook Inletkeeper; CalWild; Los Padres ForestWatch; Friends of the Inyo; Environmental Protection Information Center; Sierra Forest Legacy; Greater Hell’s Canyon Council; Central Oregon Land Watch; Cascade Forest Conservancy; Think Wild; Bird Alliance of Oregon; Rewilding Institute; Predator Defense; Save the Yellowstone Grizzly; Yellowstone to Uintas Connection; Wyoming Wilderness Association; Wildlife for All; Wild Connections; Wilderness Workshop; Sheep Mountain Alliance; San Luis Valley Ecosystem Council; Santa Fe Forest Coalition; Gallatin Wildlife Association; John Muir Project; Dogwood Alliance; Turtle Island Restoration Network; Scenic America; Izaak Walton League (Minnesota Division); Conservation Congress; Montana Environmental Information Center; Klamath-Siskiyou Wildlands Center; Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation; Native Fish Society; Umpqua Watersheds; Soda Mountain Wilderness Council, Mid-Willamette Bird Alliance; Coast to Cascades Bird Alliance; Kalmiopsis Audubon; Bark

Climate, energy and fossil fuels
Greenpeace USA; Friends of the Earth US; Oil Change International; Food & Water Watch; Earthworks; U.S. Climate Action Network; Third Act; Third Act Faith; Third Act Georgia; Fridays for Future USA; Progressives for Climate; Beyond Extreme Energy; Oil and Gas Action Network; Frack Action; Stop the (Constitution) Pipeline; Compressor Free Franklin; Elmirans and Friends Against Fracking; Santa Cruz Climate Action Network; Long Beach Alliance for Clean Energy; Clean Energy Action; Sane Energy Project; Climate Defenders; Extinction Rebellion SWCT; Climate Families NYC; Youth United for Climate Crisis Action; No False Climate Solutions PA; Climate Conversation Brazoria County; Sunflower Alliance; Institute for Policy Studies Climate Policy Program; Partnership for Policy Integrity; Property Rights and Pipeline Center; Sustain SJ; 350 Bay Area Action; 350 Yakima Climate Action; 350Hawaii; 350PDX; 350 Conejo/San Fernando Valley; 350 Triangle; 350Brooklyn; SanDiego350; Natural Resources Defense Council; Sierra Club; Breach Collective

Environmental justice and community and data center groups
Climate Justice Alliance; WE ACT for Environmental Justice; GreenLatinos; Center on Race, Poverty, and the Environment; Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice; Central California Environmental Justice Network; Michigan Environmental Justice Coalition; NC Environmental Justice Network; NC Climate Justice Collective; NC Alliance to Protect Our People and the Places We Live; Environmental Justice Task Force; Flint Rising; Port Arthur Community Action Network; Mossville Environmental Action Now; RiSE for Environmental Justice; West End Revitalization Association; Vessel Project of Louisiana; Multicultural Alliance for a Safe Environment; Cherokee Concerned Citizens; Environmental Advocates Mississippi; Rural Arizona Action; Clean Air Council; Clean Air Coalition of Western New York; Bucks Environmental Action; HALT Taylor Data Centers; No Data Center 502; No Landover Data Center Movement; Oregon Data Center Defiance; Washington AI Resistance; Kentuckians for the Commonwealth; Citizens Caring for the Future

Water, rivers and oceans
Oceana; Waterkeeper Alliance; American Rivers; Conservation Law Foundation; Delaware Riverkeeper Network; Milwaukee Riverkeeper; Columbia Riverkeeper; Save Our Wild Salmon Coalition; Columbia Riverkeeper; Association of Northwest Steelheaders; Clean Water for North Carolina; WaterLegacy; Great Egg Harbor Watershed Association; Lower San Pedro Watershed Alliance; Norton Bay Watershed Council; Black Hills Clean Water Alliance; Bitterroot River Protection Association; Seneca Lake Guardian; Tualatin Riverkeepers; The Water Collaborative of New Orleans; International Marine Mammal Project (Earth Island Institute); WaterWatch of Oregon; Willamette Riverkeeper; The Ocean Project; Inland Ocean Coalition; Waterspirit; Amigos Bravos; New Mexico Acequia Association

 

en_USEnglish
Skip to content